Our daily deli menu offers a wide variety of sandwiches. The options range anywhere from the standard corn beef on rye (#2 New Yorker) to the exotic eggplant Israeli sandwich (#31 Sabeech). Our box lunches are popular outside orders for business or family gatherings.

There may be special offers or coupons available on our specials page.

Some minimums may apply. Prices subject to change.
Printable Daily Menu (PDF)

Our daily deli menu features:

Hot Fleishig Sandwiches
Served with a pickle.
#1 Uptown

$9.50 Nosher / 13.50 Fresser

Uptown


Hot pastrami on our own grilled rye bread with deli mustard.
#2 New Yorker

$9.50 Nosher / 13.50 Fresser

Hot corned beef on our own grilled rye bread with deli mustard.
#24 Henny Penny Chicken

$5.99

Tender chicken meat simmered in BBQ sauce and served on a toasted sesame bun with red onion.
#25 Salami Slammer

$5.99 Single / $7.50 Double

Thick cut salami grilled and topped with fried onions, pickles and deli mustard on toasted sesame bun.
#30 Grilled Steak Fajita Wrap

$8.99

Marinated slices of flame broiled steak with onion, bell pepper, tomato, and cilantro wrapped in a flour tortilla.

Return to Top
Hot Combo Sandwiches
Served with a pickle.
#6 Haskel

$9.99 Nosher / 12.50 Fresser

Hot corned beef, coleslaw and chopped liver on our own grilled rye. (Chef's Favorite)
#12 Rachel

$8.50

Hot turkey with sauerkraut and Fishman's sauce on our own grilled pumpernickel.
#15 Essex

$9.50 Nosher / $13.50 Fresser

Hot beef pastrami and corned beef on our own grilled rye with deli mustard.
#27 Reuben

$10.25 Nosher / $14.25 Fresser

Hot corned beef on our own grilled rye with sauerkraut and Fishman's sauce.

Return to Top
Cold Fleishig Sandwiches
Served with a pickle.
#3 Jim's on Friday Salami

$6.99

Salami on our own rye with deli mustard. Add $2.00 for hard salami.
#5 East Side Hoagie

$6.99

Turkey and salami on a hoagie with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and Italian dressing.
#7 Haskel

$5.99

Turkey on our own hand braided challah with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
#10 Park Avenue Combo

$10.75

Park Avenue


Turkey, crisp fried pastrami, lettuce, tomato and mayo on wheat bread.
#16 Boulevard Roast Beef

$8.99

Our own roast beef on pumpernickel with onions and creamy horseradish sauce.
#28 Chicken Caesar Wrap

$7.99

Pieces of grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, garlic croutons and Fishman's own Caesar dressing wrapped in a flour tortilla.

Return to Top
Other Sandwiches
Served with a pickle.
#19 Broadway Lox and Bagel

$7.99

Nova Salmon lox with parve cream cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion on a bagel.
#20 Lake Street Tuna

$5.99

Tuna salad on wheat bread with lettuce and tomato.
#21 Falafel Sandwich

$5.99

Falafel in a pita with hummus, lettuce, tomatoes and cucumber. Served with Tahini or Schug.
#26 Veggie Burger Girl

$5.99 Single / $7.50 Double

Veggie patty served on toasted sesame bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and mayo.
#29 Veggie Lover Wrap

$7.99

Hummos, roasted red pepper, lettuce, tomato and cucumber wrapped in a flour tortilla.
#31 Sabeech (Israeli Sandwich)

$5.99

Grilled slices of eggplant with sliced hard-boiled egg, hummus, techina, shredded lettuce and Amba sauce served in a pita. (Stewart's Favorite).

Return to Top
From the Grill
Served with a pickle.
#91 Burger Big Boy

$7.95

Half pound of ground beef, flame broiled and served on a sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato, pickle and Fishman's sauce.
#97 1/4 lb Rubashkin Burger

$4.25 Plain / 5.25 With Toppings

All Beef Patty served on a toasted sesame bun.
#93 Chicken Cutlet

$7.50

Grilled chicken cutlet on a roasted sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
#32 Chicken Strips

$5.25

Hand breaded filets of chicken breast fried to crisp golden brown. Served with BBQ sauce.
#Beef Rib Steak

$19.50

Our best steak flame broiled with our special seasonings.
Hot Dog and Chicago Dog

$2.99

Chicago Style comes with onions, pickle relish, tomato, and hot pepper.
Hand Dipped Corn Dog

$3.50

Hot dog coated in cornbread batter.

Return to Top
Salads
Garden Salad

$3.75

Crisp lettuce, tomato, cucumber and red onion with choice of dressing.
Salad Platter - Chicken or Tuna

$9.99 Chicken / $8.99 Tuna

Tuna Platter


Tomato stuffed with chicken or tuna salad, served with fresh fruit, potato salad and pita.
Chef's Salad

$11.75

Chef's Salad

Crisp greens with diced cucumber, tomato, onion, egg, crisp fried pastrami and turkey. Served with pita.

Return to Top
Soups
Chicken Matzo Ball
Too Big for a Cup / $4.50 Bowl / $8.95 Quart

Chicken Noodle
$2.75 Cup / $4.50 Bowl / $8.95 Quart

Return to Top
Kids Combo Meals
Served with a french fries and a pickle. Hot Dog - $4.50
Corn Dog - $4.99
Chicken Strips - $6.75
1/4 lb Rubashkin Burger $5.75 plain / $6.75 with toppings

Return to Top
Sides
Potato Knish - $2.25
Israeli Salad - $1.99 / $3.99
Potato Salad - $1.50 / $2.99
Coleslaw - $1.50 / $2.99
French Fries - $1.99 / $3.75
Fresh Fruit - $3.99

Return to Top
Beverages
Coffee / Tea with Refills - $1.75
Iced Tea with Refills - $1.75
Fountain Soda with Refills - $1.75
Dr. Brown's Can Soda - $1.25

Return to Top
Box Lunches
Add $3.00 to Sandwich Price

Step 1. Choose any cold sandwich.
Step 2. Choose a side dish - potato salad, coleslaw, or potato chips.
Step 3. Include a pickle, an apple, our famous chocolate chip cookie and napkin and fork.
Step 4. Enjoy!

Return to Top