Our daily deli menu offers a wide variety of sandwiches. The options range anywhere from the standard corn beef on rye (#2 New Yorker) to the exotic eggplant Israeli sandwich (#31 Sabeech). Our box lunches are popular outside orders for business or family gatherings.
Some minimums may apply. Prices subject to change.
Printable Daily Menu (PDF)
Served with a pickle.
#1 Uptown
$9.50 Nosher / 13.50 Fresser
Hot pastrami on our own grilled rye bread with deli mustard.
#2 New Yorker
$9.50 Nosher / 13.50 Fresser
Hot corned beef on our own grilled rye bread with deli mustard.
#24 Henny Penny Chicken
$5.99
Tender chicken meat simmered in BBQ sauce and served on a toasted sesame bun with red onion.
#25 Salami Slammer
$5.99 Single / $7.50 Double
Thick cut salami grilled and topped with fried onions, pickles and deli mustard on toasted sesame bun.
#30 Grilled Steak Fajita Wrap
$8.99
Marinated slices of flame broiled steak with onion, bell pepper, tomato, and cilantro wrapped in a flour tortilla.
Return to Top
Served with a pickle.
#6 Haskel
$9.99 Nosher / 12.50 Fresser
Hot corned beef, coleslaw and chopped liver on our own grilled rye. (Chef's Favorite)
#12 Rachel
$8.50
Hot turkey with sauerkraut and Fishman's sauce on our own grilled pumpernickel.
#15 Essex
$9.50 Nosher / $13.50 Fresser
Hot beef pastrami and corned beef on our own grilled rye with deli mustard.
#27 Reuben
$10.25 Nosher / $14.25 Fresser
Hot corned beef on our own grilled rye with sauerkraut and Fishman's sauce.
Return to Top
Served with a pickle.
#3 Jim's on Friday Salami
$6.99
Salami on our own rye with deli mustard. Add $2.00 for hard salami.
#5 East Side Hoagie
$6.99
Turkey and salami on a hoagie with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and Italian dressing.
#7 Haskel
$5.99
Turkey on our own hand braided challah with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
#10 Park Avenue Combo
$10.75
Turkey, crisp fried pastrami, lettuce, tomato and mayo on wheat bread.
#16 Boulevard Roast Beef
$8.99
Our own roast beef on pumpernickel with onions and creamy horseradish sauce.
#28 Chicken Caesar Wrap
$7.99
Pieces of grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, garlic croutons and Fishman's own Caesar dressing wrapped in a flour tortilla.
Return to Top
Served with a pickle.
#19 Broadway Lox and Bagel
$7.99
Nova Salmon lox with parve cream cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion on a bagel.
#20 Lake Street Tuna
$5.99
Tuna salad on wheat bread with lettuce and tomato.
#21 Falafel Sandwich
$5.99
Falafel in a pita with hummus, lettuce, tomatoes and cucumber. Served with Tahini or Schug.
#26 Veggie Burger Girl
$5.99 Single / $7.50 Double
Veggie patty served on toasted sesame bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and mayo.
#29 Veggie Lover Wrap
$7.99
Hummos, roasted red pepper, lettuce, tomato and cucumber wrapped in a flour tortilla.
#31 Sabeech (Israeli Sandwich)
$5.99
Grilled slices of eggplant with sliced hard-boiled egg, hummus, techina, shredded lettuce and Amba sauce served in a pita. (Stewart's Favorite).
Return to Top
Served with a pickle.
#91 Burger Big Boy
$7.95
Half pound of ground beef, flame broiled and served on a sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato, pickle and Fishman's sauce.
#97 1/4 lb Rubashkin Burger
$4.25 Plain / 5.25 With Toppings
All Beef Patty served on a toasted sesame bun.
#93 Chicken Cutlet
$7.50
Grilled chicken cutlet on a roasted sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
#32 Chicken Strips
$5.25
Hand breaded filets of chicken breast fried to crisp golden brown. Served with BBQ sauce.
#Beef Rib Steak
$19.50
Our best steak flame broiled with our special seasonings.
Hot Dog and Chicago Dog
$2.99
Chicago Style comes with onions, pickle relish, tomato, and hot pepper.
Hand Dipped Corn Dog
$3.50
Hot dog coated in cornbread batter.
Return to Top
Garden Salad
$3.75
Crisp lettuce, tomato, cucumber and red onion with choice of dressing.
Salad Platter - Chicken or Tuna
$9.99 Chicken / $8.99 Tuna
Tomato stuffed with chicken or tuna salad, served with fresh fruit, potato salad and pita.
Chef's Salad
$11.75
Crisp greens with diced cucumber, tomato, onion, egg, crisp fried pastrami and turkey. Served with pita.
Return to Top
Chicken Matzo Ball
Too Big for a Cup / $4.50 Bowl / $8.95 Quart
Chicken Noodle
$2.75 Cup / $4.50 Bowl / $8.95 Quart
Return to Top
Served with a french fries and a pickle.
Hot Dog - $4.50
Corn Dog - $4.99
Chicken Strips - $6.75
1/4 lb Rubashkin Burger $5.75 plain / $6.75 with toppings
Return to Top
Potato Knish - $2.25
Israeli Salad - $1.99 / $3.99
Potato Salad - $1.50 / $2.99
Coleslaw - $1.50 / $2.99
French Fries - $1.99 / $3.75
Fresh Fruit - $3.99
Return to Top
Coffee / Tea with Refills - $1.75
Iced Tea with Refills - $1.75
Fountain Soda with Refills - $1.75
Dr. Brown's Can Soda - $1.25
Return to Top
Add $3.00 to Sandwich Price
Step 1. Choose any cold sandwich.
Step 2. Choose a side dish - potato salad, coleslaw, or potato chips.
Step 3. Include a pickle, an apple, our famous chocolate chip cookie and napkin and fork.
Step 4. Enjoy!
Return to Top
